Archive

Archive for January, 2012

Virginia’s Very Own Ghost Town: Penniman

January 31st, 2012 Sears Homes 1 comment

It was called Virginia’s own Ghost Town.

Penniman, Virginia, sat on the land now occupied by Cheatham Annex (near Williamsburg) and started - quite literally - as a Boom Town.

In late 1916, DuPont selected the site as their 37th munitions plant, probably because of its location:  It bordered the broad York River and it was safely away from population centers. When you’re manufacturing explosives and a mistake occurs, things go BOOM.  (Google “DuPont Munitions Plant Explosions” to find a dozen pre-WW1 examples.)

Penniman was named in honor of an American Chemist, Russell S. Penniman, who figured out how to build a better munition. Alfred Nobel’s original-recipe dynamite used nitroglycerine, but Penniman invented an ammonia-based dynamite, which was much safer than nitroglycerine.

According to an article that appeared in the Virginia Gazette, the wages paid at “DuPont Plant #37″ were so high that laborers poured in from all over the area.

“Local farmers found laborers almost impossible to hire, and certainly not at the old low wages. With thousands of men and women manufacturing shells at Penniman and living wherever they could, Williamsburg boomed. Rental space, whether for offices or for living, was impossible to find at any price. The mass exodus of workers was so great, area farmers were left wondering how they’d get their crops planted” (Meyers, Terry. “The Silence of the Graves.” Virginia Gazette June 3, 1998).

“In time,” writes Martha McCartney, author James City County; Keystone of the Commonwealth, “the [DuPont plant at Penniman] employed 10,000 people and the community bordering the plant had a population of 10,000 to 20,000″ (McCartney, Martha W.  James City County; Keystone of the Commonwealth. James City County, Virginia, Donning Company Publishing, 1997).

In August 1918, local papers reported that the United States Navy would take over the 12,500 acre facility. It would now be called, “The Naval Mine Depot.”  On  November 11th 1918, the “War to End All Wars” was over. It was President Woodrow Wilson who’d coined that phrase. Now that the earth had endured the last war that would ever be fought, it was time to dismantle Penniman.

But then something happened on the way to de-construction: The flu epidemic.

According to Meyers, the hospital at Penniman was overwhelmed with fatalities from Spanish Influenza, with bodies being shipped back to their waiting families in North Carolina, Texas, Tennessee and other southern states. Many Penniman employees had traversed great distances to find work at DuPont Plant #37, and when they died, DuPont paid a “death benefit” which helped with the costs of shipping the bodies back home, wherever that may be.  Meyers writes:

On October 12, the Daily Press reported that undertakers were being kept busy by the toll at Penniman: “the baggage cars are always full of caskets.” And on October 13 came a report that “a local [Williamsburg] undertaker had to requisition a truck to haul bodies from Penniman this morning…There is a scarcity of coffins here, the dealers having had in hand only a small stock prior to the grip epidemic  (Meyers, Terry. “The Silence of the Graves.” Virginia Gazette June 3, 1998).

By late 1920, the Spanish Flu had taken (by conservative estimates) more than 50 million lives. Penniman was now in the hands of the Navy. And it was time to get rid of the 250 houses that had been built at the DuPont Munitions Plant.

December 5, 1921, a little piece appeared in the Virginian Pilot, describing several houses being floated down to Tanner’s Creek (now the Lafayette River in Norfolk). It said the houses had been erected by the government near Yorktown. That’s not factually correct. It was DuPont that actually built these houses, just as they had done at other munitions plants in Old Hickory, TN and Hopewell, VA and Carney Point, NJ and Ramsay, MT.

The houses shown on the barges (pictures below) came from DuPont Plant #37 in Penniman, Virginia.

Now, after a great deal of research, we’ve learned that DuPont offered several models, and we’ve found these models at the DuPont cities listed in the prior paragraph. Most recently, we were able to get our hands on a picture of the houses - as they stood - in Penniman in the late 1910s. So now we have placed the houses at Penniman, and then floating on a barge, and then in place in four different Norfolk neighborhoods.

And it all started with DuPont Plant #37, site of Virginia’s very own Ghost Town.

And now for Rose’s wish list: I wish that we could find more/better photos of Penniman.

Thanks to Mark Hardin (Hopewell) and David Spriggs (Norfolk) who did most of the research for this story.

To read part II of this story, click here.

To read more about Old Hickory, click here.

To read about the Sears Homes of Norfolk, click here.

Penniman was a massive operation in its brief time.

Penniman was a massive operation in its brief time. This photo is a piece of a panoramic photo from the Library of Congress and is the only known photo of Penniman, Virginia from its days as DuPont Plant #37. I'd love to find out more about the history and source of this photo.

Photo

Clustered together, near the banks of the York River, are the DuPont Houses built for the workers. This photo is a piece of a panoramic photo from the Library of Congress.

This is the last known surviving Dupont Design at Penniman (now Cheatham Annex). This was known as The Hopewell design, and there are several of these homes at the DuPont plant in Hopewell, Virginia.

This is the last known surviving "Dupont Design" at Penniman (later called, Naval Mine Depot, and now Cheatham Annex). This particular model was known as "The Hopewell" design, and there are several of these homes at the DuPont plant in Hopewell, Virginia. About 95 years ago, this acreage would have been filled with houses, built for the workers at the plant.

The views in Penniman (and the views from our last Penniman house) would have been spectacular. Just beyond this bit of brush is an expansive view of the York River.

The views in Penniman (and the views from our last Penniman house) would have been spectacular. Just beyond this bit of brush is an expansive view of the York River. If you were standing on the front porch of our Penniman house (shown above) this is what you'd see.

The

To my utter dismay and frustration, this is the only photo I've been able to find of Penniman, as it looked in the late 1910s. This photo appeared in The Richmond Times Leader on June 22, 1938, on an article they did on Penniman. On the forefront are three "Haskells," and behind them are two "Georgia" models.

The

Sometimes, zooming in really doesn't help a lot.

The Haskell

The Haskell was a DuPont design and there's an entire community of these DuPont houses in Old Hickory, Tennessee. Apparently, there were many of these houses in Penniman.

An article in the December 5, 1921 Virginian Pilot shows these two Haskells on a barge, being floated down Tanners Creek and into Norfolk.

An article in the December 5, 1921 Virginian Pilot shows these two Haskells on a barge, being floated down Tanner's Creek and into Norfolk.

The same article also showed two Cumberlands coming here from Penniman.

The same article also showed two "Cumberlands" coming here from Penniman. They're shown here on the barge, at the end of their long journey which began on the York River.

The

The accompanying text in the December 1921 article in the Virginia Pilot.

The Cumberland was another model that was moved from Penniman to Norfolk.

The Cumberland was another model that was moved from Penniman to Norfolk.

The Haskell arrived in Norfolk, and was planted on Major Avenue. In fact, its one of 50 houses from Penniman.

The Haskell arrived in Norfolk, and was planted on Major Avenue. In fact, it's one of 50 houses from Penniman. The vintage image (of a Haskell in Old Hickory) is on the left. The Penniman house (from DuPont Plant #37) is on the right.

There are two Cumberlands on Major Avenue, next to the Haskells.

There are two "Cumberlands" on Major Avenue, next to the Haskells. The Cumberland is also seen above on the barge, being floated down Tanner's Creek.

The third housing style we have from Penniman is The Georgia. This is a modest (but cute) Dutch Colonial. You can see these in the background of the grainy photo from the Richmond News Leader.

The third housing style we've found in Norfolk (from Penniman) is "The Georgia." This is a modest (but darling!) Dutch Colonial. You can see these houses in the background of the grainy photo from the Richmond News Leader.

And it started in Riverview.

And it started with these 16 matching bungalows in Riverview (Norfolk). For years, we'd heard that these matching houses came from The Jamestown Exposition (1907), but that is NOT true. In fact, these are "Dupont Houses" and they were originally built at Penniman, and shipped by barge to Norfolk when Penniman was shut down. Later, we learned that the name of this design is "The DuPont." How apropos!

The original news article from the 1938 Richmond News Leader.

The original news article from the 1938 Richmond News Leader.

To read more about the houses that came to Norfolk from Penniman, click here.

To learn about the murder of Addie Hoyt, click here.

*   *   *

“That Photo of Addie’s Open Grave Was Shocking and Sad…”

January 31st, 2012 Sears Homes 4 comments

My great, great Aunt (Addie Hoyt)  was exhumed on November 3, 2011, and since then, I’ve received many, many questions from many people. In fact, more than 30,000 people have visited this blog since July 1st, just to read more about Addie.

Most of the folks who’ve been following this story have read that we found Addie buried in a shallow grave.  As one writer said, “When I saw that photo of Addie’s open grave, it was shocking and sad. There could not have been much soil on top of the coffin.”

Many people have expressed that very same sentiment.

When Doctors Peterson and Anapol arrived at Addie’s grave site on Thursday morning (November 3rd, the day of the exhumation), one of the first things they did was to measure the depth of the grave, and that’s where the 34″ measurement came from. But there’s also “the  rest of the story.”

None of us were expecting to find Addie in such a shallow grave. When the exhumation was in the planning stages, it had been decided to use the backhoe to 48″ and then turn off the heavy equipment and start the hand-digging. Based on conversations with two funeral directors and one long-time grave digger, it was expected that we’d find Addie at 6-8 feet.

We were wrong.

In fact, if you figure that Addie’s coffin was 16-18″ tall, that means that there was no more than 18″ of dirt on top of her coffin. Someone else asked about soil erosion, but if you look at the massive headstones throughout Rock Lake Cemetery (where Addie was buried), you’ll notice that the current placement of these headstones show no evidence of any soil erosion at the site.

And there’s another fact  about Addie’s exhumation that is utterly chilling.  When the good doctors arrived, they measured the open grave but by that time, some of Addie’s remains had been accidentally scooped up (by the backhoe) and dumped into the dump truck. In fact, that’s where a piece of Addie’s skull was found; in the dump truck.

Again - no one expected to find the remains so close to the surface.

Did Enoch murder Addie? Mary Wilson (Enoch’s granddaughter) says that yes, he did.  And given the rest of the information we have about Addie’s death, Ms. Wilson’s accounting of the facts looks quite accurate.

We do know that this “bereaved husband” didn’t care enough about his 29-year-old dead wife to arrange for a proper burial. He couldn’t be bothered to give her a legal burial. He couldn’t be bothered to follow the state law and get a burial permit. He couldn’t be bothered  to dig a proper grave. He couldn’t be bothered to give her a proper wake or funeral service.

Ah, but old Enoch did take the time to pry her wedding jewelry off her cold, dead  fingers before he dropped her into a shallow grave in the wee hours of June 19th.

These few facts - independent of Mary Wilson’s accounting of events - tell us a lot about Enoch James Fargo.

And none of it is good.

Shocking and sad

"Shocking and sad"

Shocking

All of Addie's remains have been removed from this grave - thank goodness.

You have to wonder how such a beautiful young woman ended up with Enoch.

You have to wonder how such a beautiful young woman ended up with Enoch.

To learn more about Addie, click here.

*   *   *

Burial At Shovel Depth?

January 29th, 2012 Sears Homes No comments

Three months ago, I was in Lake Mills, Wisconsin making the last-minute arrangements for my Aunt Addie’s exhumation. In June 1901, she was murdered by her 52-year-old husband, Enoch James Fargo. The number one question I’m asked again and again is, “Are you glad you did it, even though the autopsy results were inconclusive?”

In a word, yes.

Without the exhumation, we never would have known that Addie was buried in an extremely shallow grave. We would never have known that she was buried in her black, lace-up dress boots. Those are two important facts, and two more details that corroborate Mary Wilson’s story that Enoch murdered Addie.

Burial

Back in late November, a very unhappy Lake Mills resident sent me a note that said Addie was buried at "shovel depth" and that her burial depth of 34" was not that big a deal. If Addie was buried at "shovel depth," they must have been using THIS shovel.

*

Addie

This little shovel is only 26" long, so maybe they went down an extra 8", just to be safe?

*

This photo really demonstrates how shallow Addies grave was.

This photo demonstrates the shallowness of Addie's grave .

*

According to Mary Wilsons book (A History of Lake Mills), Enoch James Fargo murdered his young wife, Addie Hoyt in June 1901.

According to Mary Wilson's book ("A History of Lake Mills"), Enoch James Fargo murdered his young wife, Addie Hoyt in June 1901. What makes this so remarkable is that Mary Wilson was Enoch's own granddaughter. In later years, Mary told friends that the story came from her mother (Elsie Fargo Mccammon) who would have been Enoch's own daughter.

*

The exhumation was quite a logistical nightmare, but I was shown no little kindness by many kind souls in Lake Mills.

The exhumation was quite a logistical nightmare, but in the end, I'm very glad that I did it, if for no other reason than to get Addie out of that shallow grave. She deserves better.

*

Addie was only 29 years old when she was murdered by Enoch. He was 52 years old, and he bribed a local doctor to falsifying Addies death certificate.

Addie was only 29 years old when she was murdered by Enoch.

*

In addition to burying her illegally (with no burial permit) and tossing her into a shallow grave (in the dark of night) and stripping off her wedding jewelry before burying her (which was not in accord with the traditions of the day), this fine citizen of Lake Mills married his third wife only seven months after Addies tragic death. Oh, and the woman he married, was living in the Fargo Mansion when Addie was killed.

In addition to burying Addie illegally (with no burial permit) and tossing her into a shallow grave (in the dark of night) and stripping off her wedding jewelry before burying her (which was not in accord with the traditions of the day), this fine citizen of Lake Mills married his third wife only seven months after Addie's tragic death. And the woman he married (Martha Harbeck Hoyt) was living in the Fargo Mansion when Addie was killed. Suspicious? Quite. Scandalous? Absolutely.

*

Burial

The burial permits were in chronological order. Addie's permit number should have been number 22, but despite a thorough examination of all the permits, I found none with Addie's name. It was a direct violation of state law for *anyone* to be buried in a public cemetery without a burial permit.

*

State law also required that a dwelling be fumigated after a communicable disease had occurred (such as diphtheria). Enooch Fargoo violated state law AGAIN when he did not hav the Fargo Mansion fumigated after Addies death.

State law also required that a dwelling be fumigated after a communicable disease had occurred (such as diphtheria). Enoch Fargo violated state law AGAIN when he did not have the Fargo Mansion fumigated after Addie's death.

*

Addie

According to Addie's death certificate (which was falsified), her burial permit was #32, but in fact, that belonged to Alinda Hornikle who died on March 27, 1902.

*

To learn more about Addie, click here.

*    *   *

The Exhumation of Addie Hoyt

January 28th, 2012 Sears Homes 2 comments

“We’ve found her remains,” the grave digger said, gesturing toward the cordoned-off area that included Addie’s grave site.

“What?”

My mono-syllabic response was not so much a genuine inquiry as it was a statement of surprise. The backhoe had just started digging. The plan was that the backhoe would go down to a depth of 48 inches, and then the hand-digging would commence. Based on conversations I’d had with two long-time funeral directors, we were expecting to find Addie’s remains at 6-8 feet. We’d come prepared, too. We had buckets and ladders and ropes and shovels, and most importantly, several volunteer diggers.

As soon as I’d spoken, I became aware that the roar of backhoe had ceased. In fact, now that I thought about this, I realized the backhoe had only been running for a few minutes.

It was 37 degrees that morning at Rock Lake Cemetery in Lake Mills, Wisconsin, and the sky was a solemn, solid gray with thick cloud cover. A steady wind drove the damp cold air deep into my southern bones. Born and raised in Southeastern Virginia, I was not accustomed to this bitter cold. Underneath my borrowed, bulky winter coat, I was wearing two thick undershirts, and two heavy flannels buttoned up to the neck. On top of the four shirts, I had a light-weight windbreaker, and the heavy coat represented the sixth layer of fabric.

And yet, despite all those layers of warm, comfortable clothing, a funny thing happened when the grave digger told me that they’d found her remains.

I began to shake uncontrollably and my knees went weak.

In an effort to steady myself, I put my arm around my friend Randy, and leaned hard into his tall, sturdy frame. This was the very reason I’d asked Randy to come. He was tall and steady and kind and he was an old soul. And I was far from home and frightened and tired and nervous as a cat. This whole affair - the legal proceedings and financial expenses and logistical headaches - had all been very stressful.

I’d asked Randy to attend the exhumation and to provide moral and spiritual support. He’d graciously accepted.

With my arm around his waist, I grabbed a handful of his black wool dress coat and closed my fist tight. If I fainted and fell to the ground, I wanted to go down slowly and with a modicum of grace. Randy already had his arm around my waist and I felt him pull me tighter and closer. I was comforted by this tangible expression of compassion. Randy Otto wasn’t going to let me fall down on his watch.  I held fast to Randy. My legs still felt inadequate to the task of holding me up.

It was a very emotional moment.

They’d found Addie’s remains.

For months, I’d wondered how I’d react at this moment. For months, I’d wondered if my great, great Aunt Addie was even in that grave. The fact that Addie’s husband (Enoch Fargo) never obtained a burial permit for Addie (a specific violation of Wisconsin state law) left me wondering if she was buried in the grave that bore her name, or if her body had been disposed of in some more sinister fashion. It seemed like everyone in Lake Mills knew the 110-year-old story - that Enoch murdered his second wife, Addie - but many folks in Lake Mills had different ideas on how he’d killed her, and a handful of people wondered if Addie had been buried elsewhere.

The discovery of remains was good news. But if she was in the grave, why hadn’t Enoch obtained a burial permit for her? How did he bury her without a burial permit?  Such an act was blatantly illegal in 1901. Enoch’s own uncle (Robert Fargo) was the cemetery’s sexton in 1901. Obtaining a burial permit from Uncle Bob would have been simple. Or maybe Enoch was so arrogant as to think that the laws did not apply to someone as powerful as himself? But if that’s the case, why was Addie’s death certificate falsified, to show that a burial permit had been obtained (even including a fictitious permit number)?

The answers to those questions would have to wait for now. Today, I was relieved that they’d found remains in Addie’s grave.

The grave digger asked if I’d like to look at the now-open grave. I said that I would. Randy and I walked together toward the grave site, navigating around the cheap orange plastic fence that had been required by the city (and paid for by me). We entered the fenced area and walked over to the grave. My first impression was that the grave was barely knee-deep.

Why is the grave so shallow, I wondered as I cautiously leaned over the hole to get a better look.  In Fall 2009, my husband was building a magnificent pergola in the back yard when we found a dead dog buried at about three feet of depth. The image of that little dog buried in the yard popped into my mind. Wouldn’t you bury a human being a little deeper than a family pet?

But I had a thousand other thoughts racing through my mind at that moment. That’s probably not a completely accurate statement. It was more like a million thoughts dashing and darting around in my head, jockeying for position at the forefront.

As I peered into the rich, dark Wisconsin soil, the grave digger held up a rust-colored twig, about 3/8″ thick and 7-8″ long.

Why are they showing me a piece of tree root, I thought to myself.

“What is that?” I asked, feeling truly sorry for these guys who’d just gone to all this trouble of turning off the backhoe, and stopping the excavation, all because they’d found one little twig in the hole.

“That’s a bone,” Mr. Grave Digger responded.

“A bone? Are you sure? Are you sure that’s not a stick?”

Thanks to the distraction the little stick provided, I noticed I’d stopped shaking and shivering.

“Yes, it’s a bone,” he replied. He seemed very confident about this.

Given that I’m a writer and Mr. Grave Digger was, well, a full-time grave digger, I decided I’d better trust his proclamation.

By now, David Olsen had sashayed over next to me, and was also peering into the grave. I leaned towards David and quietly asked, “David, do you really think that’s a bone?”

David Olsen was the funeral director who was there to “assist the family” (that’d be me and Addie), and he’d also volunteered to drive Addie’s remains to Milwaukee for autopsy. David Olsen was also the very specific answer to my many, many prayers, where I implored God to send me some “really big angels.” In addition to being at least 6′5″, David was one of the kindest, most compassionate people I’ve ever encountered. Much like Randy, David was another “old soul,” and a real class act.

David leaned his massive frame down toward me and softly said, “Yes, Rose that’s definitely a bone. Old bones are porous, and they take on the color of the soil around them. It’s rust-colored because of the dirt around it.”

That made a lot of sense.

I glanced at my watch. During the prolonged period of six-layer dressing earlier in the day, I’d gone to great pains to keep it uncovered and free. It was now a little past 9:00 a.m.

“The two experts,” (as they came to known by our group) were due to show up at any moment.

In late August 2011, someone in Lake Mills suggested that I contact Dr. Brian Peterson, Milwaukee Medical Examiner and ask if he’d be willing to do the autopsy on Addie Hoyt. Dr. Peterson and I had our first phone conversation on September 7th. He was intrigued by Addie’s story, and said that it was a pretty unusual case and he very generously offered to donate his services for the autopsy. I was elated. Dr. Peterson suggested I contact Dr. Anapol, a professor of anthropology from the University of Wisconsin at Milwaukee. I did, and Dr. Anapol was also interested in the case.

A few weeks later, I was delightfully surprised to learn that both men were planning to attend the exhumation, and from there, the good news just kept coming. Dr. Anapol would be bringing strong, able-bodied students from UWM, who’d be ready, willing and able to jump down into the old grave and start digging.

The morning of the exhumation, I’d ‘awakened at 2:30 a.m.  At 6:00 a.m. I had begun the long, arduous process of dressing for the cold. I started pulling shirts out of my suitcase and putting them on, one by one. It took a few tries to figure out the exact order of the layering process.  At 6:45 a.m., I was done. I could no longer bend my arms at the elbows, but at least I’d be warm.

I left the Fargo Mansion Inn (where I’d been staying) and started the one-mile drive to the cemetery. I left a little earlier than I really needed to. I drove extra slow.

I’d visited Addie’s grave site too many times to count, so I knew just where to park. I walked to her headstone and said a little prayer for her, and for me. Speaking out loud, I told Addie, “We’re going to do this right, Addie. You may not have been honored at the end of your earthly life, but you’re going to be honored in death. I promise you that.”

In addition to the heavenly thoughts, I was facing some earthly problems. I was cold. Really, really cold.  I started wondering how in the world I would be able to stand outside in the frozen tundra of southern Wisconsin for several hours. It was not even 7:25 a.m., and I was already thinking about what it feels like to die from hypothermia. I’d read years ago that people get very sleepy right before they freeze to death. I was feeling very sleepy all of a sudden. How ironic that would be, I thought, if the grave diggers came for the exhumation and found my frozen, lifeless form, snuggled up against Addie’s granite headstone, eyes wide open in ceaseless wonderment with snowy-white icicles hanging from my long eyelashes.

When it was time to lie down and die from hypothermia, I made a mental note to remain on Addie’s side of the tombstone. Enoch’s name was inscribed on other side. I didn’t want to be anywhere near him when death came calling.

When I stopped pondering my imminent demise from hypothermia, my thoughts turned back to The Big Dig (as my family affectionately described it). I now vacillated back and forth between, “Thank God, this day has finally come and this will soon be over,” to “I must be out of my mind to be standing here in Lake Mills, waiting to dig up a long-dead relative that I never even met.”

My husband and I had just purchased a new home in Norfolk, Virginia, and it was our dream house. Why wasn’t I back home in Virginia, sitting in my back yard and gazing out upon Lake Whitehurst, watching the Hooded Mergansers and Double Crested Cormorants swim to and fro? What was I doing here in Lake Mills, standing under these depressing gray skies in an old cemetery?

My thoughts were interrupted by the sounds of an approaching car. It was about 7:30 a.m., and it was Reverend Bill McBride, arriving just as promised. He was dressed in his religious attire, which I very much appreciated. We’d had a long visit the day before in his office, and I had asked him to perform a blessing of the ground, for both my benefit, and Addie’s. In that blessing, I’d also requested that we pray for the safety of the workers, and that in all in attendance be guided by Divine intelligence and guarded by God’s love.

Reverend McBride, who knew the details of Addie’s tragic death, prayed that she would be guided into the light of God’s love, escorted by God’s own angels, and covered in God’s mercy and grace. He prayed that Addie’s soul would find “heavenly rest and perfect peace.”

At the end of his prayers, we prayed together for a moment.

That brief, ten-minute service was one of the most beautiful, hallowed and sacred moments of my time on this earth. Imagine, standing at the grave site of a murdered relative on a quiet winter’s morning when the sun has barely crested the horizon, with a Christly, holy man like Reverend McBride by your side, and praying for God’s blessing before you open the grave to remove a long-dead body. It was remarkable and above all, it was holy.

When our service was over, I wiped a few tears from my eyes and thanked him. He said he had to leave for a bit, but that he’d return in two hours for the actual exhumation. I walked him to his car, thanked him again and said goodbye.

Just as Reverend McBride was getting ready to go, I saw a little Honda navigating the labyrinthine roadways of Rock Lake cemetery. It was  my dear friend Heather. She’d come to keep me company, and wait with me.

Dear Heather lived almost an hour away, just outside of Milwaukee. A few days earlier, when she’d generously asked if there was anything she could do for me, I asked her to get up on Thursday morning, well before sunrise, and drive 50 miles to Rock Lake Cemetery in Lake Mills and hold my hand.

She readily agreed. Another earthly angel.

A little bit later, the cemetery sexton arrived and joined us at Addie’s graveside. He told us that the grave diggers - the guys with the backhoe - should be arriving any minute.

As Heather and I stood there, huddled together for warmth, a city official parked his car and quickly walked toward the grave. The first words out of his mouth were, “I hear this thing has been called off. I got a call at 9:00 o’clock last night that we’re not doing this today.”

The sexton said, “Are you joking?”

The sexton said it, but it’s what I was thinking, too. While we awaited his response, I felt my heart sink down to my knees. I could hardly breathe for a moment, but I tried to retain my composure.

We’d come too far to have this thing go off the rails now.  Way too far.

To be continued.

Wife #3 (Martha Harbeck) died in 1964, and according to cemetery officials, her coffin was placed within a vault. The boundaries of the vault were marked to make sure that her remains would not be disturbed.

Wife #3 (Martha Harbeck) died in 1964, and according to cemetery officials, her coffin was placed within a vault. The boundaries of the vault were marked to make sure that her remains would not be disturbed. Martha and Addie's plots were side by side. Enoch and the first wife were on the other side of the family marker.

The morning of November 3rd, the backhoe stands ready and poised. Photo is copyright 2011 Heather Lukaszewski and can not be used or reproduced without written permission.

The morning of November 3rd, the backhoe stands ready and poised to start digging at Addie's grave at Rock Lake Cemetery. (Photo is copyright 2011 Heather Lukaszewski and can not be used or reproduced without written permission.)

There was a fairly large group there, many of whom were city officials who (apparently) just wanted to observe the exhumation.

There was a fairly large group there, many of whom were city officials who (apparently) just wanted to observe the exhumation. This photo was taken shortly after Addie's memorial service. The lone face visible in the crowd is Reverend McBride. (Photo is copyright 2011 Heather Lukaszewski and can not be used or reproduced without written permission.)

This photo really demonstates the shallowness of Addies grave. It was measured and found to be at 34 deep. By anyones standards, thats incredibly shallow.

This photo really demonstrates the shallowness of Addie's grave. It was measured and found to be at 34" deep. Turns out, we didn't need those ladders.

Addie was 29 years old when she was murdered by her husband of five years, Enoch James Fargo. Seven months after killing his second wife, he married his third wife. In 1901, this would have been considered scandalous.

Addie was 29 years old when she was murdered by her husband of five years, Enoch James Fargo. Addie is shown here with her sister (my great grandmother), Anna Hoyt. In this photo, Addie (left) is 15 years old. Her sister would have been 21. In another 14 years, Addie would be dead.

Seven months after killinig his second wife, 52-year-old Enoch married his third wife, 28-year-old Martha Harbeck Hoyt. To marry during the mourning period would have been considered scandalous on a level we can scarcely imagine today.

Seven months after killing his second wife, 52-year-old Enoch married his third wife, 28-year-old Martha Harbeck Hoyt. To marry during the mourning period would have been considered scandalous on a level we can scarcely imagine today.

Addies falsified death certificate states that she died from diphtheria. Enoch Fargo violated state law when he did not obtain a burial permit for Addies burial, and he violatd state law a second time when he did not have the Fargo Mansion fumigated. Wisconsin State Law required that the household be fumigated after a communicable diseasess such as diphtheeria.

Addie's falsified death certificate states that she died from diphtheria. Enoch Fargo violated state law when he did not obtain a burial permit for Addie's burial, and he violated state law a second time when he did not have the Fargo Mansion fumigated after Addie's death. Wisconsin State Law required that the household be fumigated after communicable diseases such as diphtheria.

The story has its roots in this book, The History of Lake Mills. Enochs own granddaughter - Mary Wilson - wrote, Enoch shot Addie (p. 274).

The story has its roots in this book (green book, top shelf), "A History of Lake Mills." Enoch's own granddaughter - Mary Wilson - wrote, "Enoch shot Addie" (p. 274). (Photo is copyright 2011 Heather Lukaszewski and can not be used or reproduced without written permission.)

To learn more about Addie, click here.

*    *    *

The Sears Homes of St. Louis (Kirkwood)

January 27th, 2012 Sears Homes 1 comment

When I first started this Sears House gig, I lived in Alton, IL (near St. Louis) and some of my first discoveries were in the St. Louis area. Below are the Sears Homes I’ve found in the Kirkwood area (part of St. Louis). If you enjoy the link, please share it with friends!

What is a Sears Home? These were true kits containing 12,000 pieces of house. Each kit came with a 75-page instruction book that told you how to put all those pieces and parts together. The houses were sold out of the pages of the Sears Roebuck catalog, and the houses in St. Louis were shipped from Cairo, Illinois. Sears offered these houses from 1908-1940 and there were 370 different designs. Today, the only way to find these homes in literally one by one.

These photos were scanned from slides, taken in 2002 and 2003, so they’re a little faded.

Enjoy the photos! And if you want to learn how to identify kit homes, click here.

One of the reasons there are so many kit homes in St. Louis is because there was a Sears Modern Homes sales center in St. Louis. There were only 40 of these in the country, and these were only placed in areas where sales had been strong. And once a Modern Homes sales center opened, sales were even stronger!

One of the reasons there are so many kit homes in St. Louis is because there was a Sears Modern Homes sales center in St. Louis. There were only 40 of these in the country, and these were only placed in areas where sales had been strong. And once a Modern Homes sales center opened, sales were even stronger!

*

In the late 20s, there was one at

In the late 20s, there was one at 8th and Olive Streets (from the 1928 catalog).

*

And in the early 30s,

And in the early 30s,it had moved to the Wainright Building.

*

A full listing of the Sears Modern Homes sales centers appeared on the back of the 1930 catalog.

A full listing of the Sears Modern Homes sales centers appeared on the back of the 1930 catalog.

*

The Sears Lynnhaven, as seen in the 1938 catalog.

The Sears Lynnhaven, as seen in the 1938 catalog.

*

This Lynnhaven has had a not-so-thoughtful addition, but theres no mistaking it as a Sears Lynnhaven.

This Lynnhaven has had a not-so-thoughtful addition, but there's no mistaking it as a Sears Lynnhaven.

*

Another Sears Lynnhaven in Kirkwood. This photo was taken in 2003.

Another Sears Lynnhaven in Kirkwood. This photo was taken in 2003.

*

The Cedars was a beautiful tudor-esque cottage (1928 catalog).

The Cedars was a beautiful tudor-esque cottage (1928 catalog).

*

And heres a *perfect* Cedars! Fortunately (as of 2003), it still has its original siding - CEDAR shakes!

And here's a *perfect* Cedars! Fortunately (as of 2003), it still has its original siding - CEDAR shakes!

*

The Chatham was a cute little Dutch Colonial.

The Chatham was a cute little Dutch Colonial.

*

And here it is!

And here it is, complete with the bellcast porch roof.

*

The Sears Mitchell was one of their most popular models!

The Sears Mitchell was one of their most popular models!

*

And heres an unusually beautiful Mitchell in Kirkwood.

And here's an unusually beautiful Mitchell in brick and stucco.

*

The Sears Berwyn was also a very popular house for Sears.

The Sears Berwyn was also a very popular house for Sears.

*

Sears Berwyn in brick!

Sears Berwyn in brick! I'm not certain, but I think this house is actually in Richmond Heights. If you know its location, please leave a comment below!

*

The Sears Montrose (from the 1928 catalog) was not a popular house!

The Sears Montrose (from the 1928 catalog) was not a popular house!

*

A perfect Montrose!

A perfect Montrose tucked away in the pines!

*

Sears Brookwood as seen in the 1933 catalog.

Sears Brookwood as seen in the 1933 catalog.

*

A picture-perfect Sears Brookwood in Kirkwood!

A picture-perfect Sears Brookwood in Kirkwood!

*

Barrington, from the 1928 catalog. The Barrington and the Brookwood look very similar. The Barrington is a little bit bigger than the Brookwood. For a time, I had trouble keeping these houses separate in my mind. And then I thought of this visual clue. The Barrington has three windows in the living room (on the first floor front). The Barrington is a three-syllable word. The Brookwood has two syllables and two windows! Voila!

Barrington, from the 1928 catalog. The Barrington and the Brookwood look very similar. The Barrington is a little bit bigger than the Brookwood. For a time, I had trouble keeping these houses separate in my mind. And then I thought of this visual clue. The Barrington has three windows in the living room (on the first floor front). The Barrington is a three-syllable word. The Brookwood has two syllables and two windows! Voila!

*

The Sears Barrington, with its three windows!

The Sears Barrington, with its three windows!

*

Someone told me this was a Sears kit house. My, but I stared at this house for hours and hours and I could not figure it out. Then finally, the owners invited me to come into their home and take a better look. Thats when I discovered - it WAS a Sears Home - slightly altered.

Someone told me this was a Sears kit house. My, but I stared at this house for hours and hours and I could not figure it out. Then finally, the owners invited me to come into their home and take a better look. That's when I discovered - it WAS a Sears Home - slightly altered.

*

Its a Sears Wilmore, turned sideways on the lot!

The house in Kirkwood is a Sears Wilmore, turned sideways on the lot!

*

Words

Notice the bellcast (swoopie) roof on the end of the house? This house is turned sideways on the lot, with that bellcast (shown in the catalog picture above on the left) turned out to the street. In other words, the house in Kirkwood was placed on this lot at a 90-degree angle to the catalog image. The main gable (shown above with the two windows) has been extended out several feet to make a larger living room. The front door was easily moved into that front gable. Pretty interesting changes!

*

To learn more about Sears Homes, click here.

To buy Rose’s book, click here.

*   *   *

The Back Story of “The Houses That Sears Built”

January 26th, 2012 Sears Homes 5 comments

In February 2012, it will have been 10 years since I published my book, The Houses That Sears Built. Writing that book was a labor of love, but it was also an incredibly intense experience.  By Christmas 2001, I had nearly finished the manuscript.

For our Christmas vacation that year, our family (my husband and three daughters) had planned to fly to Portsmouth, Virginia to visit our families. (We were living in the St. Louis area at the time.)

About three weeks before the holidays, I decided to cancel my plans and stay home and finish up the manuscript. I was on a roll, and after two years, it was time to put my nose to the grindstone and get it done. But one of those “little voices” told me that this was an important trip, and that I needed to stick with the plan and spend Christmas in Portsmouth.

On Christmas Eve, we had dinner with my mother.  We were so happy to see her, and spend time with her. And I had a surprise. I’d just had a big article published in a national magazine.  She was so proud of me, and asked me to read the article out loud to her, which I did. My dear mother looked at me and just beamed.

“My beautiful daughter,” she said with a big smile. “My beautiful famous daughter. I’m so proud of you.”

And at that moment, I almost slipped and told her my secret: My new book was going to be dedicated to her, Betty B. Fuller. The inscription would read, All that I am or hope to be, I owe to my angel mother. I remember my mother’s prayers and they have always clung to me.

It was a quote from Abraham Lincoln and it described exactly how I felt.

Throughout my life, my mother’s prayers had been such a blessing and support. She was always my #1 cheerleader and my dearest friend.

That night, when we left her house, I told her that we’d be back in just a few hours - on Christmas morning!  She hugged me tight and started swaying side to side a little bit, while whispering in my ear, “My beautiful daughter. I love you so much.”

The next morning, she didn’t answer the door and she didn’t answer the phone. I used my key to get into the house and that’s when we found her - still in bed - ashen and barely breathing.  She never regained consciousness, and died a short time later.

Twelve days later, I returned home, hardly able to think about that book of mine. Suddenly, it seemed so completely unimportant.  However, I eventually pulled myself together enough to finish it and take the manuscript to the printer.

That was February 2002. Later that month, my husband of 24 years told me that he now understood Paul in the Bible, and that like Paul, he realized he was not the marrying kind. He asked for a divorce. And so ended a relationship that had begun in 1968. I’d met Tom when I was in third grade.

I moved out of the family home, and into a low-rent singles’ apartment and tried desperately to start a new life.

The Houses That Sears Built - was more than just a book. It became my raison d’être, literally.  The book - and the career that came with it  - gave me a sense of purpose and pride and unspeakable joy. Less than 60 days after its publication, I was interviewed for a feature article in the New York Times. That was a wonderful break.

Next, I was invited to appear in a new show being developed for PBS, tentatively titled, The History Detectives. From there, I ended up on A&E’s Biography, CBS Sunday Morning News and more. In July 2004, my book made it to Jeopardy!

By Summer 2006, I’d done more than 500 interviews and had appeared in almost every national newspaper in America, including, Christian Science Monitor, Dallas Morning News, Los Angeles Times, and the Washington Post. In June 2006, my story appeared in the Wall Street Journal - front page - and above the fold! That was the coup of my career.

And in Summer 2006, I met Wayne Ringer. Six months later, we were married.

I’ve always believed in God’s timing, and the timing of this book’s publication and the start of my new life could not have possibly been any better.

And it was FUN. I traveled all over the country and was a featured speaker at countless venues and seminars and preservation conferences and I was treated like a queen. I really liked being treated like a queen!

The book - and the career that followed - restored my soul and healed my shattered self-esteem. Divorce is tough.

In 2004, I traveled to a small town in the Midwest, and stayed at a Marriott Hotel. The organizers of the event had made all the arrangements for me, and that was always much appreciated. When I checked in at the desk, the clerk looked up from her computer screen, smiled at me and said, “You’re Rosemary Thornton?”

I said, “Yes,” and she reached her hand across the counter and said, “Can I shake your hand? I’ve always wanted to meet a real author.”

It was (and still is) one of the best memories of my career.

And it all started with one little self-published tome on Sears Kit Homes.  Ten years ago, this month.

Only 3,000 copies of this first edition were sold, and by then, Id written an updated version, which has sold almost 15,000 copies now.  The first edition now fetches a handsome price.

Only 3,000 copies of this "first edition" were sold, and by then, I'd written an updated version, which has been in print since February 2004. The first edition (now out of print) fetches a handsome price.

*

In May 2006, I gave a talk here.

In May 2006, I gave a talk in Jefferson City, Missouri. While in Jefferson City, I had my first telephone conversation with Wayne, the man who'd become my husband.

*

In 2010, The History Press contacted me and asked if Id be interested in writing a coffee-table book on Sears Homes. The Sears Homes of Illinois was the result, and this was - without any doubts - my last book on kit homes.

In 2010, "The History Press" contacted me and asked if I'd be interested in writing a coffee-table book on Sears Homes. "The Sears Homes of Illinois" was the result, and this was - without any doubts - my last book on kit homes.

To learn more about kit homes, click here.

To see the kit homes of Norfolk, click here.

*   *   *

Sears Kit Homes in My Town: Norfolk, Virginia

January 24th, 2012 Sears Homes 4 comments

How many Sears Homes does Norfolk have? A whole bunch. In fact, Norfolk has more than 75 kit homes from a variety of kit-home companies, including Aladdin, Sears, Lewis Manufacturing, Harris Brothers and Gordon Van Tine.

When I first started hunting for kit homes in Norfolk, I was expecting to find a couple dozen - at the most. I was surprised (and delighted) to find so many of them, and in diverse group of neighborhoods, such as West Ghent, Ingleside, Larchmont, Ocean View, Park Place, Colonial Place, Riverview, Lafayette Winona and more.

Born and raised in Portsmouth, I’ll always be a “Portsmouth Girl.” In 1995, our little family left Hampton Roads and moved to the St. Louis area, where we lived for 11 years.  In 2006, I moved back to the area, met and married a nice guy who worked for the city of Norfolk, and that’s when Norfolk became my new home.

I’m still learning how to navigate the labyrinthine streets, and still making new discoveries. Who knew Norfolk could be so much fun?  :)

To read about the Sears Homes I found in Newport News, click here.

The Sears Roanoke, as shown in the 1920 Sears Modern Homes catalog.

The Sears Roanoke, as shown in the 1920 Sears Modern Homes catalog.

*

Of all the houses Ive found in Norfolk, this is far and away my #1 favorite. This is an older picture, but its a perfect Sears Roanoke in Norfolk (off of Colley Avenue). The owner (Robert) loves his beautiful Roanoke, and Ive never come across *anyone* who loves (and respects) the historical significance of his Sears House, more than this fellow. The house is a gem, and thanks to Robert, this 90-year-old home has been faithfully and meticulously restored.

Of all the houses I've found in Norfolk, this is far and away my #1 favorite. This is a perfect Sears Roanoke in Norfolk (off Colley Avenue). The owner (Robert) loves his beautiful Roanoke, and I've never come across *anyone* who loves (and appreciates) the historical significance of his Sears House, more than this fellow. The house is a gem, and thanks to Robert, this 90-year-old home has been faithfully and meticulously restored.

*

The Sears Lebanon, as seen in the 1919 catalog.

The Sears Lebanon, as seen in the 1919 catalog.

*

Another treasure of a house, and also in good condition. Its on 28th Street, just off Colley Avenue.

Another treasure of a house, and also in good condition. It's on 28th Street, just off Colley Avenue. See the small pieces of wood that jut out under that dormer window? Those are the old supports that held up the flower boxes (seen in original catalog image).

*

The Whitehall is easy to identify with that two-story bay window (1926).

The Whitehall is easy to identify with that two-story bay window (1926).

*

Next door to the Sears Lebanon is this Whitehall (27th Street).

Next door to the Sears Lebanon is this Whitehall (28th Street).

*

Sears Argyle (1919 catalog).

Sears Argyle (1919 catalog).

*

This sweet little Sears Argyle is hidden away in the 900-block of 28th Street.

This sweet little Sears Argyle is hidden away in the 900-block of 28th Street.

*

Heres another Argyle in Ocean View.

Here's another Argyle in Ocean View.

*

The Alhambra was another popular Sears kit home.

The Alhambra was another popular Sears kit home.

*

Heres a modified Alhambra on Westover Avenue in Ghent.

Here's a modified Alhambra on Westover Avenue in West Ghent. It's one of three exact models, all in a row. A distinctive feature of the Alhambra is the three squared-bay windows.

*

The Alhambra floorplan shows those three squared bays.

The Alhambra floorplan shows those three squared bays.

*

One of my favorites is the Harris Brothers La Grange (1923 catalog).

One of my favorites is the Harris Brothers "La Grange" (1923 catalog).

*

There are two of these in Ocean View. Heres one on Capitol Avenue.

There are two of these in Ocean View. Here's one on Capitol Avenue. Notice the curved front porch, and casement windows flanking the fireplace.

*

Not surprisingly, there are many Aladdin kit homes in Norfolk. Aladdin was a bigger company than Sears, and remained in business un 1981. Aladdin had a huge mill at Wilmington, NC.

Not surprisingly, there are many Aladdin kit homes in Norfolk. Aladdin was a bigger company than Sears, and remained in business un 1981. Aladdin had a huge mill at Wilmington, NC.

*

There are two of these Aladdin Edisons right next door to ODU in the 800-block of 46th Street.

There are two of these Aladdin Edisons right next door to ODU in the 800-block of 46th Street.

*

Aladdin Virginia from the 1919 Aladdin catalog.

Aladdin Virginia from the 1919 Aladdin catalog.

*

Aladdin Virginia on Virginia Avenue in the state of Virginia!

This Aladdin "Virginia" is on Virginia Avenue in the state of Virginia (in Colonial Place). It's in wonderful condition and it's a spot-on match to the original catalog image.

*

The Aladdin Pasadena and there are three of them in Norfolk.

There are three Aladdin Pasadenas in Norfolk.

*

This Aladdin Pasadena is in the 1600-block of LaSalle Avenue in Lafayette-Winona.

This Aladdin Pasadena is in the 1600-block of LaSalle Avenue in Lafayette-Winona.

Its turned sideways on the lot, which made the initial identification a little challenging, but theres no doubt that this is a Pasadena. Look at the detail around the front porch.

It's turned sideways on the lot, which made the initial identification a little challenging, but there's no doubt that this is a Pasadena. Look at the architectural details around the front porch. This house is on 49th Street in Norfolk.

*

Close-up of the porch on this sideways Pasadena.

Close-up of the porch on this sideways Pasadena.

*

The Aladdin Winthrop is easy to identify with those four bricks columns on the porch, only two of which have wooden columns extending to the porch roof.

The Aladdin Winthrop is easy to identify with those four bricks columns on the porch, only two of which have wooden columns extending to the porch roof. Another interesting feature is the window in the side of the dining room bay.

*

This Aladdin Winthrop is even the same colors as its original catalog image. Its in the 3000-block of Tidewater Drive.

This Aladdin Winthrop is even the same colors as its original catalog image. It's in Lafayette Winona, and it's in beautifully original condition!

*

The Sheffield as seen in the 1919 catalog.

The "Sheffield" as seen in the 1919 catalog.

*

This one is in Lafayette-Winona.

This one is in Lafayette-Winona, and it's a perfect match!

*

The Aladdin Pomona, as seen in the 1919 catalog.

The Aladdin Pomona, as seen in the 1919 catalog.

*

The Aladdin Pomona in Lafayette-Winona.

The Aladdin Pomona in Lafayette-Winona. The windows have been changed but it's undoubtedly a Pomona. And it's in a neighborhood with several Aladdins!

*

The Plaza was a grand house, and spacious too.

The Plaza was a grand house, and spacious too.

*

And here is my #1 favorite kit house in all of Hampton Roads: The Aladdin Plaza, in beautifully original condition.

And here is my #1 favorite kit house in all of Hampton Roads: The Aladdin Plaza, in beautifully original condition.

*

Gordon Van Tine was another mail-order kit home company that was based in Davenport, Iowa.

Gordon Van Tine was another mail-order kit home company that was based in Davenport, Iowa. This design ("The Roberts") was one of their most popular houses.

*

This Roberts is in Ocean View and is beautiful condition!

This "Roberts" is in Ocean View and is beautiful condition!

*

The Glenn Falls was one of Sears biggest and best kit homes (1928 catalog).

The Glenn Falls was one of Sears biggest and best kit homes (1928 catalog).

*

And this one is in West Ghent!

And this one is in West Ghent!

*

The Sears Avondale was a popular house.

The Sears Avondale was a popular house (1919 catalog), and spacious, too.

*

And this one is on Victorian Avenue. Its well-hidden by the trees, but theres no doubt that its a Sears Avondale.

And this one is on Victoria Avenue. It's well-hidden by the trees, but there's no doubt that it's a Sears Avondale. This is a mirror image of the catalog page above. Notice the large bay window? It's on the "flip side" of the catalog picture.

*

The Sears Vallonia was one of Sears best-selling homes (1925 catalog).

The Sears Vallonia was one of Sears best-selling homes (1925 catalog).

*

Located in Ocean View (on Mason Avenue), its been converted into a duplex, but its definitely a Vallonia.

Located in Ocean View (on Mason Avenue), it's been converted into a duplex, but it's definitely a Sears Vallonia, with an enlarged dormer.

*

Sears Westly, as seen in the 1919 catalog.

Sears Westly, as seen in the 1919 catalog.

*

And a Sears Westly on Tennesee Road. This was a real surprise, because most of these houses are post-1940s.

And a Sears Westly on Tennessee Road. This was a real surprise, because most of the houses on this street are post-1940s.

*

And heres a Sears Westly (now a duplex, sadly) in Ocean View.

And another Sears Westly (now a duplex, sadly) in Ocean View.

*

The Sears Barrington was a popular house (1929 catalog).

The Sears Barrington was a popular house (1929 catalog).

*

This Barrington is in Ocean View, and its a good match to the catalog picture.

This Barrington is in Ocean View, and it's a good match to the catalog picture.

*

The Sears Americus is also easy to identify, because that bumped-out wall on the second floor does not exist on the first floor.

The Sears Americus is also easy to identify, because that bumped-out wall on the second floor does not exist on the first floor. The porch roof also catches my eye, because it juts out beyond the home's main wall, and is shaped like a sideways "V."

*

This Americus is in Park Place is in the 600-block of 27th Street. Park Place has several kit homes.

This Americus is in Park Place is in the 600-block of 27th Street. Park Place has several kit homes. There's a special place in hell for the guy who did this siding job. Look what he did to the eave brackets. Plus, like so many other Sears Homes in Norfolk, it's been turned into a duplex.

*

There is not one, but two Aladdin Venuses (or woult that be Venii?) in Park Place.

There are two Aladdin "Venuses" (or would that be "Venii"?) in Park Place.

*

This Aladdin Venus still has its original casement windows. Its on 38th.

This Aladdin Venus still has its original casement windows. It's on 38th Street.

*

And this Aladdin Venus is on 36th Street.

The Venus was offered in two floor plans. There was a Mama Bear-sized Venus and a Papa Bear-sized Venus. This one (on 36th street) is the larger model. The one on 38th Street (shown above) was the smaller model.

*

Norfolk is also home to many plan book houses. Plan books were akin to kit homes, but with plan book homes, you ordered the blueprints and a list of building materials that would be needed. The actual building materials were then obtained locally.  This house shown here is a Homebuilders Carrville.

Norfolk is also home to many "plan book" houses. Plan books were akin to "kit homes," but with plan book homes, you ordered the blueprints and a list of building materials that would be needed. The actual building materials were then obtained locally. This house shown here is a "Homebuilder's Carrville."

*

And heres a pristine example in Ocean View.

And here's a pristine example in Ocean View. The Ocean View home has straight gables, unlike the catalog image, which has the clipped gables. That minor alteration would have been easy to do.

*

Putting these photos together took about 50 hours of work (spread out over a period of months). Looking for kit homes is always fun, but after a few hours, both Teddy and I come back home dog tired.

Putting this blog together took about 50 hours of work (spread out over a period of months). Finding these early 20th Century kit homes is always fun, but also a bit tiring. After a few hours of "house hunting," Teddy and I usually return home "dog tired."

As mentioned, there are more than 80 kit homes in Norfolk. The above are just a few of them.

Please share this link with friends!

To learn more about the kit homes in Ocean View, click here.

To see pictures of kit homes in Colonial Place, click here.

*   *   *

A Not-So-Nobby Neighborhood in Newport News With Numerous Kit Homes!

January 21st, 2012 Sears Homes 5 comments

It’s called, “East End,” and it’s a badly blighted, crime-ridden part of the otherwise lovely, history laden city of Newport News (Virginia). Despite the fact that I’m a native of Tidewater, I never knew this neighborhood existed, until I stumbled upon it while looking for a particular house in Hampton!

After my fortuitous stumble into East End, I discovered a Sears kit home I had never seen before. After 12 years of playing with kit homes, that doesn’t happen too often these days. And yet here it was, in Newport News, which is next door to Norfolk (where I live). To learn more about these early 20th Century kit homes, click here.

The next day I returned to East End to get a better photo of this Sears House, and I found several more kit homes. I returned a couple days later and spent 90 minutes driving to and fro in this neighborhood. It’s my hope and prayer that this research might encourage the important people in Newport News to think about what can be done to preserve and protect this truly remarkable collection of kit homes.

As I told my husband, this is the type of discovery I’d expect to make in a Chicago suburb (where there’s an abundance of kit homes). Here in Virginia, I’ve never seen anything quite like this. And due to the straitened economic circumstances of this neighborhood, some of these houses are in largely original condition. (In addition to the Sears kit homes, I also found several houses from Aladdin, which also sold entire kit houses through mail order. In fact, I found more Aladdin kit homes than Sears!)

The research and writing of this blog consumed many, many hours of my life. Please share this link with others, who may have any interest in our cultural and architectural history.

Enjoy the many photos and please leave a comment below.

The first house that caught my eye was this Sears Model #119. Its a grand old house, and the house in Newport News is the first one Ive seen in person.

The first house that caught my eye was this Sears Model #119. It's a grand old house, and the house in Newport News is the first one I've ever seen "in the flesh."

*

Hard to believe, but someone built this house from a kit. These houses arrived via train, and came with 12,000 pieces and a 75-page instruction book. I can only imagine how hard it was for this homes original builder to leave this wonderful home. More than 50% of the time, these homes were built by average men and women who were just trying to capture a piece of the American Dream.

Hard to believe, but someone built this house from a kit. These houses arrived via train, and came with 12,000 pieces and a 75-page instruction book. I can only imagine how hard it was for this home's original builder to leave this home that he'd built - with his own hands - for his family. These homes were built to last for GENERATIONS, and they were made with superior quality building materials. This house is on Marshall Avenue.

*

Side-by-side comparison of the two houses.

Side-by-side comparison of the two images.

*

The Hathaway was a cute little house, and affordable, and probably not too tough to build.

The Hathaway was a cute little house, and affordable, and probably not too tough to build.

*

Here it is, in PRISTINE condition. Notice that even the original lattice work is still in place, and is a spot-on match to the catalog image. Just incredible! Probably one of my favorite finds!

Here it is, in PRISTINE condition, and sitting unobtrusively on Hampton Avenue (in Newport News). Notice that even the original lattice work is still in place, and is a spot-on match to the catalog image. Just incredible! Probably one of my favorite finds!

*

A comparison of the two images shows

A comparison of the two images. What a treasure!

*

Just as I was getting ready to head home, I turned down 26th Street and lo and behold, what did I see, but a PERFECT Aladdin Brentwood smiling back at me!

Just as I was getting ready to head home, I turned down 26th Street and lo and behold, what did I see, but a PERFECT Aladdin Brentwood smiling back at me! This image (shown here) is from the 1914 Aladdin catalog. This is a classic Arts & Crafts design, and a beautiful house.

*

A perfect Aladdin Brentwood. Made me gasp out loud, followed by paroxsyms of great joy.

A perfect Aladdin Brentwood. When I happened upon this house, I made a high-pitched happy noise, followed by paroxysms of great joy. But this poor old Aladdin Brentwood is in rough shape, and needs quite a bit of work. The balcony's railing (upper left of photo) is literally falling off the house. This house is across the street from the Pearl Bailey Public Library.

*

Side by side comparison to the two houses.

Side by side comparison to the two houses. Pretty sweet house!

*

The Aladdin Venus, as seen in the 1919 Aladdin catalog.

The Aladdin Venus, as seen in the 1919 Aladdin catalog. The L-shaped front porch is a distinctive feature on the Aladdin Venus.

*

And here it is.

What is it about this color and Aladdin Homes in East End?

*

Another very nice match.

Another very nice match. As a side note, photographing this house was very difficult, as it was on the right side of the road on a one-way street (26th Street), and I wasn't prepared to park the car, and hoof it to the house just to get a good shot.

*

The Sears Westly, as seen in the 1919 catalog.

The Sears Westly, as seen in the 1919 catalog.

*

And heres a Sears Westly.

And here's a Sears Westly in good condition on 23rd Street.

*

Again, a very sweet match to the original catalog picture!

Again, a very sweet match to the original catalog picture!

*

The Aladdin Marsden was probably one of their top five most popular houses.

The Aladdin Marsden was probably one of their top five most popular houses.

*

Look at the deatil of the brickword around the chimney!

Look at the detail of the brickwork on the chimney!

*

And its for Better class workers!

This Sears Home was for "Better class" workers!

*

Ouch.

Ouch. At least the satellite dish is dressed up for the holidays.

*

Compare

Poor little "Carlin."

*

Lewis Manufacturing was yet another early 20th Century kit home company.

Lewis Manufacturing was yet another early 20th Century kit home company.

*

I suspect this *may* be a Lewis Pelham, but Im not convinced.

I suspect this *may* be a Lewis Pelham, but I'm not convinced. There are a lot of things that are "just right" and match the Pelham very nicely. Notice the squared bay with a shed roof, and the four round columns on the front porch. It's a good match to the Pelham, but not perfect. Hard to see here, but in "person" you can tell that four windows in that gabled dormer were removed and sided over. And check out the action on the back roof. This classic bungalow is becoming an A-Frame. Icky.

*

If you look closely at these windows, you can seem that a few have been blanked out and covered up.

If you look closely at this dormer, you can see that a few windows have been removed and covered up.

*

From the 1910 catalog, this is the Sears Model #123.

From the 1910 catalog, this is the Sears Model #123.

*

This house in East End is SO close, but just not quite right.

This house in East End is SO close, but just not quite right. This house has so many odd architectural details (the pedimented porch, the two different-size dormers on the side, the bay under the larger dormer), but it's not 100% perfect.

*

At the end of the day, Teddy and I were tired, and ready to come home.

At the end of the day, Teddy The Amazing House Hunting Dog was tired, and ready to move on to the next adventure - LUNCH! We'd both had an exciting day with lots of fun discoveries, but we were glad to come home and chow down on some tasty kibble.

*

I’m confident that there are many more kit homes in this small part of Newport News, and I hope to return one day (with a driver), and do a little more searching. It’s hard to focus on houses when there are so many people milling about in the street.  :(  Plus, while I was in this area, I saw TWO drivers blow past stop signs, without even pausing to glance at traffic. Scary. And then sometime last night, some poor soul was shot repeatedly in this very area.

Please leave a comment below, and please share this link with friends, via Facebook, twitter or even plain old email!

To learn more about the kit homes of Hampton Roads, click here.

*   *   *

To Celebrate Addie’s 140th Birthday…

January 18th, 2012 Sears Homes 3 comments

In honor of Addie’s 140th birthday (January 22), I’m asking that the readers of this blog make a donation to PADA of Jefferson County, an advocacy group for victims of domestic abuse. There’s a Paypal button on the PADA website, which makes donating a few dollars simple and fast. Any amount would be appreciated, even if it’s just a couple dollars.

Addies 140th birthday is January 22nd. To honor her memory, please make a donation to PADA.

Addie's 140th birthday is January 22nd. To honor her memory, please make a donation to PADA.

Perhaps if there’d been a resource like PADA in 1901, Addie would have lived to be an old woman. Maybe she would have accomplished great things with her life, and had a chance to leave her mark on the world. Maybe - just maybe -  she would have championed Women’s Rights, or even used her inheritance from Enoch to start a shelter for abused women in Lake Mills.

But Addie did not survive her marriage to Enoch. By the age of 29, she was dead, allegedly murdered by her own husband.

Women’s lives are most at risk when they’re attempting to leave their husband or romantic partner. Many years ago, one of my dear friends was escorting a woman friend to her car after work. This woman had recently left her abusive husband after years of trying to get away. They had just stepped out into the parking lot, when the enraged “soon-to-be-ex” showed up, and quickly pulled a gun from his jacket pocket and shot his wife in the face, killing her instantly.

I wonder if Addie was attempting to leave the Fargo Mansion that summer’s night in June 1901, when things got out of hand. I wonder if Enoch was tired of her involvement with the D.A.R., or maybe he was tired of her many out-of-town trips. I wish I knew. And I won’t stop searching until I find out what happened to Addie that night - good or bad.

From time to time, anonymous writers tell me that there’s no way someone as powerful and rich and prominent as Enoch would have slapped or struck his sweet young wife. I say those people are misinformed. That’s one factor.  And here’s another:  It was a different world in 1901.

One hundred years ago, if a woman “got out of line,” it was her husband’s prerogative - perhaps even his duty - to smack her around a little bit. Women were considered to be emotionally on par with children, and it was up to the man to “keep her in line.”

Addie’s life ended when she was 29, and her husband’s alleged involvement in her murder, and the falsification of her death certificate were not investigated at the time of her death. Sadly, justice came a little late for Addie, but fortunately, Addie is no longer in the shallow grave where Enoch placed her 110 years ago. To read more about the exhumation and autopsy, click here.

There’s a lot more evidence that makes it clear, Addie did not die of diphtheria.  To read more about that, click here.

Join me - this week - in honoring Addie’s memory by making a donation in her name to PADA.

Addie and I thank you.

Addie

Addie in 1896 (left) and 1901 (right), after five years of marriage to Enoch. Note the swollen lip, misaligned philtrum (indent under the nose) and puffy eye. Life with Enoch was not easy.

*

This appeared in the local paper about three weeks after Addies death. The legend tells that diphtheria provided Enoch with just the excuse he needed to get Addie in the ground immediately, before anyone discovered that shed died from a gunshot wound. Her funeral was held at 10:00 am the morning after shed been shot. Supposedly, she died around 2:00 am. Pretty fast burial.

Based on what we know now, diphtheria could not have been Addie's cause of death. The question is, what did happen to Addie, that those present at her death felt they must cover up the truth with this lie of diphtheria?

*

com

My great-grandmother (Anna Hoyt Whitmore) was 44 in this photo. Anna (left) and Addie (right) were sisters. Addie was 29 in this photo. I've posted this photo to show what Addie might have looked like as she aged. Anna Hoyt Whitmore (left) lived to be 99 years old.

*

Close-up

Addie was a beautiful young woman.

*

My favorite photo of all.

Addie Hoyt in her bedroom, shortly after her marriage to Enoch.

*

The fam sitting in front of the house in Lake Mills, WI. Enoch is at the top, with Addie below him. Enochs two daughters are Elsie and Mattie.

Addie sitting in front of the house in Lake Mills, WI. Enoch is at the top, with Addie below him. Enoch's two daughters are Elsie (top right) and Mattie (lower right). Elsie (1876-1959) married a McCammon. Mattie (1883-1956) became Mattie Fargo Raber. It was Elsie that told her daughter (Mary Wilson) that Enoch killed Addie.

*

First, my favorite. I assume this was a traveling outfit for Addie, judging by the little bag at her side.

Addie Hoyt, all dressed up for travel, and ready to go.

*

Addie, about 1899.

Addie was a snappy dresser.

To learn more about Addie, click here.

*  *   *

Lost in Schenectady!

January 16th, 2012 Sears Homes No comments

In 2004, Dale Wolicki invited me and Rebecca to visit him in Michigan. One of our stops was Bay City, where we saw all manner of Aladdin kit homes, including “The Oxford.” Our wonderful tour guide (Dale), told us that the photograph of the Oxford model (shown in the 1931 catalog) was the very same Oxford that had been built in Bay City. It was the “original model,” and the only Oxford in Bay City.

Sears was the most-well known of the kit home companies, but Aladdin was bigger.  Aladdin was the first kit home company, starting business in 1906. Sears started two years later, in 1908. Aladdin outlasted all the others, remaining in business until 1981. Sears sold about 70,000 kit homes. Aladdin sold more than 75,000.

To learn more about Aladdin, click here.

I’ve only seen two Oxfords in my travels. The first was in Bay City, MI and the second was in Lorain, Ohio. And apparently, there’s a third one in Schenectady, NY (according to the testimony below).

Sch

The flared front gable makes this house very distinctive. Image is from the 1931 catalog.

*

And theres one

And there's one in Schenectady, NY, built by Mr. and Mrs. H. L. Newell.

*

Heres the house we saw that day with Dale. Its in Bay City, and is the same house shown in the 1932 catalog above.

Here's the house we saw that day with Dale. It's in Bay City, and is the same house shown in the 1931 catalog above. This photo was taken in 2004. Must have been July, because there's no snow on the ground.

*

Flo

I love this floorplan. Notice the "Radio Room" on the first floor! This was a room dedicated to that most important appliance - the radio! Today, we build entertainment centers bigger than this!

*

Secon

The largest bedroom is a mere 12 by 13. Not very big!

*

The 1931 catalog had a two-page spread on the Oxford.

The 1931 catalog had a two-page spread on the Oxford, and yet the captions mention that some of these images are NOT pictures of the Oxford.

*

My favorite feature in this little 1931 catalog are the interior views.

My favorite feature in this little 1931 catalog are the interior views. The caption states that two small bedrooms were turned into one large bedroom.

*

Living

Nice big living room. Love the furniture.

*

Kit

But this classic 1931 kithcen is the best room in the house.

*

And it has a breakfast nook.

And it has a breakfast nook. I have a thing for breakfast nooks. Again, this is apparently NOT the Oxford's kitchen because there's no provision for a breakfast nook in the floorplan.

Click here to read more about breakfast nooks.

The cover of the 1931 Aladdin catalog is a study unto itself.

The cover of the 1931 Aladdin catalog is a study unto itself.

To read more about the cover of this Aladdin catalog, click here.

To learn more about Sears Homes, click here.

*   *   *