Home > Uncategorized > Montrose - or Something Like It…

Montrose - or Something Like It…

Sometimes, looks can be really deceiving.

Take Hubby for example. He’s a handsome fellow, and a tough-as-nails litigator, and yet he has a tender heart and a sweet nature.

Wayne

Wayne, the hubby. With his Christmas tie. And his tender heart.

*

And heres another place where looks can be deceiving.

And here's another place where looks can be deceiving: Sears Homes and their clones. These are two different houses - theoretically. They sure do look alike.

*

This is a Sears Montrose.

This is a Sears Montrose (1928).

*

This is not.

This is a design from the 1923 Homebuilder's Catalog: "The Arlington."

*

Heres the floorplan for the Sears Montrose (1st floor).

Here's the floorplan for the Sears Montrose (1st floor).

*

Heres the floorplan for the other house.

Here's the floorplan for the Homebuilder's Arlington.

*

Heres a comparison of the two - side by side.

When you compare the two side-by-side, you can see some minor differences, but not a lot. They're almost the same house. Interior room dimensions were shifted just a wee bit, but other than that, these two are mighty close.

*

And a comparison of the second floor.

And a comparison of the second floor shows a few other minor differences - again - mainly with room dimensions. And these are line drawings, so the proportions are not always accurately reflected.

*

So how do you distinguish these look-alikes? How can you tell if its a Sears House (or an Aladdin, or GVT or Lewis), or its twinkie from Homebuilders?

So how do you distinguish these look-alikes? How can you tell if it's a Sears House (or an Aladdin, or GVT or Lewis), or its twinkie from Homebuilder's?

*

Its a question that may have no easy answer.

It's a question that may have no easy answer. Shown above is a Montrose in Kirkwood, MO.

*

And within my collection of Sears Montroses - I am left wondering, how many of these are Homebuilders designs?

And within my collection of Sears "Montroses" - I wonder, how many of these are Homebuilder's designs? (House shown above is in Moorefield, WV.)

*

Its a puzzler!

It's a puzzler! (Portsmouth, Virginia)

*

Good thing theres only one Wayne! ;)

Good thing there's only one Wayne! ;)

*

To learn more about the Montrose, click here.

Want to learn how to identify kit homes? Click here.

*

  1. December 29th, 2015 at 12:09 | #1

    Those darn pesky clones!

    I imagine there are a lot of misidentified kit homes out there given the fact that they, Sears etc, acquired popular patterns for use in their kits quite often.

    I think that from the street we are SOL. We can say it appears to be _____ .

    The only way to positively id one of the “clones” is an interior inspection for millwork and materials , possibly stenciling and/or shipping labels and maybe even a mortgage.

  1. No trackbacks yet.

Additional comments powered by BackType